On 10 November 2026 the United Kingdom’s Privy Council delivered a unanimous judgment that struck down the sections of Trinidad and Tobago’s Sexual Offences Act criminalising consensual anal sex. The ruling reversed a 2025 decision of the local Court of Appeal that had reinstated the offence, effectively ending a ten-year legal campaign led by LGBTQ activist Jason Jones. The council, which serves as the final appellate body for many Commonwealth nations, framed the matter as a breach of fundamental human dignity, asserting that the ability to love freely is a core interest of every person.
Jones, a Trinidadian-British lawyer who has lived in London for decades, hailed the decision as a watershed moment for Lgbtq rights in the Caribbean. While he acknowledged that courtroom victories do not instantly transform societal attitudes, he stressed that the judgment removes the criminal label that has long shadowed gay and bisexual citizens, allowing them to live without the threat of prosecution.
A decade of litigation: from high court victory to Privy Council triumph
The legal battle began in 2016 when Jones challenged the 1925 colonial statute, often referred to as the “buggery law”. In 2018 Justice Devindra Rampersad ruled that sections 13 and 16 of the 1986 Sexual Offences Act, which punished consensual anal intercourse, were unconstitutional. The judge’s remedy decriminalised the act for adults over sixteen and eliminated the archaic term “gross indecency”. However, the government appealed, arguing that the provisions were protected by the savings clause: a provision that preserves pre-independence legislation from constitutional scrutiny.
In March 2025 the Court of Appeal accepted the government’s argument, reinstating the criminal provisions and sending the case back to the highest appellate forum. Undeterred, Jones appealed to the Privy Council, asserting that the 1986 amendment constituted new legislation rather than a mere continuation of the colonial law, and therefore should not be shielded by the savings clause. His persistence kept the issue alive on the legal front for another year.
The Privy Council judgment and its legal reasoning
The Privy Council, comprising five senior judges, concluded that the 1986 Sexual Offences Act was indeed “new legislation” and not covered by the savings clause. Lord Sales, delivering the judgment, quoted that “the ability to form a deep connection with another person through an intimate and loving relationship is a vital interest for all human beings.” By rejecting the notion that the act was merely a relic, the council opened the door for constitutional challenges to other inherited statutes across the region.
The decision reinstated Justice Rampersad’s original remedy: consensual anal sex between adults aged sixteen or older is legal, and the offence of “gross indecency” is abolished. Jones welcomed the outcome, stating, “We may not see the benefits of this for 50 years, but at least we have removed the criminal label that made us prisoners in our own homes.” His lawyer, Caroline Edwards, described the ruling as an “emphatic victory for everyone who believes in the fundamental rights of every individual.”
Regional ripple effects and reactions
Legal experts predict that the judgment will serve as a precedent for other Caribbean jurisdictions that still rely on the Privy Council as their Supreme Court. Activist Peter Tatchell noted that at least a dozen countries could invoke the decision to challenge their own buggery statutes. Recent judgments in St Lucia and Belize have already begun to erode colonial-era anti-gay laws, and the new ruling reinforces that regional trend.
Despite the legal breakthrough, local organisations such as Pride TT caution that discrimination in employment, housing, healthcare and education remains pervasive. They stress that decriminalisation is only the first step toward full equality. Nonetheless, the ruling injects fresh momentum into advocacy across the Caribbean, offering a powerful legal tool for activists fighting to dismantle antiquated statutes that violate the human rights of LGBTQ people.



