Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth has again justified the language he used to describe transgender service members, calling it “weird” and referring to them as “dudes in dresses.” The remarks, taken from his 2024 book and past social-media posts, are now at the center of a federal lawsuit challenging the Trump administration’s ban on transgender, nonbinary, and gender-nonconforming personnel. The Justice Department (DOJ) filed a series of motions on Friday seeking to keep Hegseth’s statements out of the evidentiary record, arguing they do not prove discriminatory intent.
Legal fight over the transgender military ban
The case, filed as Talbott v. Trump, was brought by a coalition of active-duty service members and prospective recruits who argue the executive order issued in January 2025 violates the Equal Protection guarantee of the Fifth Amendment. Plaintiffs are represented by a slate of LGBTQ+ advocacy groups and litigation firms, including GLAD Law, the National Center for Lgbtq rights, Wardenski P.C., Zalkind Duncan & Bernstein LLP, Kropf Moseley Schmitt PLLC, and O’Melveny & Myers LLP. In March 2025, U.S. District Judge Ana C. Reyes temporarily blocked the ban, describing it as “soaked in animus and dripping with pretext.”
Reyes scheduled a hearing for Monday, moving it to a teleconference format, to address a dispute over evidence gathering. The judge previously limited the scope of Hegseth’s deposition, allowing only ten written questions instead of a seven-hour live testimony, but warned that inadequate answers could trigger a limited, one-hour oral deposition.
Hegseth’s testimony and the DOJ’s evidentiary strategy
In sworn written answers dated October 28, Hegseth reiterated his description of transgender people as “weird,” stating, “Men pretending to be women is ‘weird’ because men cannot be women and women cannot be men.” He also repeated the “dudes in dresses” phrase and an anti-transgender slur, arguing that individuals with gender dysphoria should be excluded from service. When asked which part of President Trump’s executive order he disagreed with, Hegseth answered, “None.” He also defended a May 2025 tweet that read “No More Trans @ DoD,” explaining that he sometimes uses “trans” as shorthand for those experiencing gender dysphoria.
The DOJ does not contest that Hegseth made the statements. Instead, its motion argues that the remarks reflect concerns about medical fitness, unit cohesion, and deployability, not unconstitutional hostility. The department asks the court to assess the policy’s written rules rather than the secretary’s rhetoric, asserting that the ban targets a medical diagnosis rather than gender identity.
Former Pentagon officials’ testimony
The government also seeks to exclude testimony from retired Pentagon leaders who oversaw personnel policy when transgender troops served openly. Retired Navy commander Shawn Skelly testified that no readiness or cohesion problems were attributable to transgender service. Former Army official Yvette Bourcicot argued that the waiver requirements imposed by the ban are effectively unattainable for many transitioning service members. A report by former acting Under Secretary of Defense Ashish Vazirani showed that transition-related health care cost an average of $5.2 million annually: less than 0.01 percent of the Department of Defense’s $60.2 billion health budget for fiscal 2024.
Despite these data points, DOJ lawyers claim that retired officials cannot reliably assess the current policy and that courts should defer to the present military leadership. In a separate filing, the department acknowledged that the ban does cut some careers short, citing a factual admission that service members without a waiver face forced separation.
A two-week bench trial is set to begin on January 4, with the upcoming teleconference hearing serving as the first step in a tightly contested legal battle. The outcome could determine whether Hegseth’s own words are admissible evidence and, more broadly, whether the transgender military ban survives judicial scrutiny.



